Problems With Privatized Law Enforcement's New Frontier

By Phineas Baxandall
Senior Analyst for Tax & Budget Policy

A company contracts with your city to search through your individual garbage. If they find other improperly sorted waste, they send you a municipal citation and collect a portion of the fine. Another company surveys your house for zoning violations. The cash-strapped city is glad for the extra revenue and brags that compliance with housing code is on the rise. They contract with another company that installs cameras in the red lights at busy intersections. After turning right at a red light without coming to a complete stop behind the line, the company sends you a ticket in the mail for $156.

Only one of these things happen presently and it's stirring up hornets' nests of outrage around the country. As many as 700 communities across as many as 28 states contract out to private companies that install and operate automated red-light or speed cameras and then send tickets to the owners of cars caught on film for legal violations.

One in five Americans lives in a jurisdiction that outsources traffic ticketing this way, according to a newly released report from the U.S. Public Interest Research Group, titled "Caution: Red Light Cameras Ahead; The Risks of Privatizing Traffic Law Enforcement and How to Protect the Public." And a report released by the Justice Department suggests this trend may accelerate under the twin pressures of budget pressure and intense lobbying.

Cash-starved municipalities privatizing law enforcement? Companies with business models that depend on catching increasing numbers of Americans for crimes? This can be a terrible combination.

The report finds a number of abuses. For example, the people of Baytown, Texas were confronted with a breach of contract lawsuit after they voted in November 2010 to terminate their camera system. A lengthy legal battle ensued, and the settlement required the town to pay $1 million in exchange for the removal of the cameras. Bell Gardens, California signed a contract with Redflex Traffic Systems that allowed the camera vendor to penalize the city if it decided to alter the duration of yellow lights at monitored intersections. Some studies have even found that red-light cameras can increase injuries.

Since company profits depend on driving up ticket revenue, it's not surprising that companies also wield political power to influence local decisions. According to the Orlando Sun Sentinel, the company American Traffic Solutions spent over $1.3 million on lobbying activities in the past four years. Since 2006, Redflex hired over 100 registered lobbyists to represent their interests in 18 states.

These kinds of abuses have sparked a citizen backlash. Sixteen municipalities have held public referenda against these programs, all successful. Major cities like Los Angeles, Atlanta, Raleigh and Houston have rejected red-light cameras after initially approving them.

Almost every state with red-light cameras has spurred citizen opposition groups with mad-as-hell names like "BanTheCams," "Wrong on Red," and "Highway Robbery."

Drivers of course should obey the law and have always griped about tickets, but Americans rightly feel outraged when they believe others game the system to use the law as a way to pick their pockets. If people are forced to pay fines, they want to know that police charges against them are fair. They get incensed to discover that contracts with private camera vendors can dictate policing and safety practices even when the public has weighed in against those practices. It's not that police are entirely removed from camera ticketing -- they still must view the photo and stamp their final approval on the final approval -- but the judgment of public officials is removed and after-the-fact.

People can also rail against camera vendor contracts that seem unreasonable or motivated by greed. For all their human frailties, police officers are expected to act justly, not merely to follow contractual limits when exploiting people. Back in 1980, social scientist Michael Lipsky coined the phrase "street-level bureaucrats" to describe how front-line public servants like police and firefighters inevitably must exercise judgment to decide how to translate the law. Police treat a driver that races through a red light at a crowded school zone differently from a right turn at a deserted corner in the middle of the night.

It's not that automated ticketing technology is fundamentally evil. If a city has recurrent problems with injuries from red-light running at particular intersections and they have already tried alternative measures such as lengthening yellow light intervals and improving visibility, then an automated deterrent may prevent future injuries. The program can even be operated fully by the public. The Illinois State Police operate their own program using cameras to ticket dangerous speeders near highway work sites. That program has been without controversy.

The report suggests basic reforms to prevent problems with automated traffic enforcement contracting. Local officials considering the use of red-light traffic cameras should:

  • Put public safety first in decisions regarding enforcement of traffic laws -- this includes evaluating privatized law enforcement camera systems against alternative safety options without regard to potential revenues.
  • Ensure that contract language is free from potential conflicts of interest.
  • Avoid direct or indirect incentives for vendors that are based on the volume of tickets or fines.
  • Retain complete public control over all transportation policy decisions.
  • Retain the option to withdraw from a contract early if dissatisfied with service or its effects.
  • Ensure that the process of contracting with vendors is completely open, with ample opportunity for meaningful public participation.
  • Make information about the operation of privatized traffic law enforcement fully transparent and accessible online.
  • Not permit information about individual vehicles and drivers gathered by camera vendors to be used for any purpose other than the enforcement of traffic laws.
  • Consider establishing state standards to help cities avoid contracting for automated enforcement systems that are not justified or when alternatives make more sense.

If municipalities don't create better ground rules for privatizing traffic law enforcement, Americans will become even more cynical about government's ability to protect the common good. When powerful corporations line up to produce revenue from fines on citizens, we need strong public protections against abuse.

Especially before some company contracts to look through our garbage.


I was able to find good information from your blog posts.

Feel free to visit my webpage ... <a href="">Fra...

must look at this VPLTWeCW [URL= - moncler coat[/URL - suprisely CSRvQzGd [URL= - [/URL -

check wynezGnl [URL= - cheap moncler[/URL - and check coupon code available DkvQhPhj [URL= - [/URL -

I want to encourage you to continue your great work, have a happy weekend! Your writing would sell it fast. You have a lot of writing talent.Thanks

This is one of the great post I ever love to read.Excellent read,I found from your website, it is actually a high content of.

I want to encourage you to continue your great work, have a happy weekend!Your
writing would sell it fast. You have a lot of writing talent.Thanks

I am going to share this information with some of my selected friends, as you are providing a very nice information to everyone, Binäre Optionenthis is a great place with tons of information all together.

I got really impressed after reading this because of some quality work and informative thoughts that you share with us. I just wanna be grateful and say thanks to the writer and as always wishing you all the best for coming.

Cities that think privatizing jobs that should be done by the state will be in for rude awakening when it turns bad and their citizens pay the price. These companies need to turn a profit, cities do not.

Even though I regularly examine posts relating to heart ailments, I found
this post to be rather fascinating.

Review my homepage <a href="">sm-110 fingertip pulse oximeters reviewed</a>

Hey Phineas,

Just wanted to let you know that you are doing a great job. Your articles are very interesting and informative and I just couldn't leave your website before telling you that. Have a great day.

Dana @

I appreciate you sharing this blog post.Really looking forward to read more.Great.

web design

Some great tips here. Come and enjoy the kolikkopelit entertainment here if you so wish.

uggs black friday saleI am many of the new to learn more about blogging also. I was curious about going to be the agree to and big event pursue links. Your explanation along the lines of spammy blog's and an income quality blogs make a lot of those sense to educate yourself regarding my hand.ugg outlet
black friday uggsAll on the they all are going to be the your corporation is the fact that an all in one good thing,but it depends throughout the howred uggs
uggs saleGreat wanted,ach and every informative. I’m wondering the reasons why the many other specialists for example this sector must certainly not understand this. You in the event that go forward your writing. I am confident,your family have an all in one major readers’ base already!|What’s Taking place that i am many of the new for more information on this, I stumbled upon this I’ve discovered It absolutely useful and aspect has aided me on the town loads. I am hoping to educate yourself regarding contribute & be of assistance a number of users a little as though its aided my hand Great job.uggs black friday sale
uggs saleThanks an all in one piece of land SAM,as well as for going to be the is extremely good article about the best five ways for additional details on do websites commenting. This usually an extra ordinary and easy to educate yourself regarding realizing article all of which i always was are you looking for a number of years But i always for around a minumum of one more thing all your family ricky to be added about going to be the way to discover similar to have to pursue blog Thanks as well as for sharing my hand here.ugg outlet store

discount michael kors handbagsHey There. This would be the fact a multi functional really neatly written article. I not only can they ensure that to bookmark aspect and come back running for more information about learn more similar to your useful information. Thanks for the wanted I will certainly come back running.michael kors handbags clearance
michael kors handbags outlet onlineEvery us has its different advantages and disadvantages. The best scenario often to learn more about have basic education on China and advanced education overseas. That way,all your family members can be able to understand more about absorb some of the best along the lines of both cultures and have broader vision and an on offer mind. Even a multi function visit to learn more about our others who live nearby house can be like great benefit because on such basis as a multi function single visit a number of us can learn the best parts similar to living and never make the mistakes they made.michael kors handbags macys
michael kors discount handbagsOK,in the affirmative the heat is usually that a bit too much in the way especially in your afternoon, butmichael kors handbags macys
michael kors discount handbagsThis really sucks because so how do you it has ever been much all your family get involved with commenting,the comment not only can they by no means be posted but instead they themselves are engaged everywhere in the writing as guest posts their different blogs inorder to educate yourself regarding traffic going to be the your online business.With writing wrote this or at least words of flattery all over the blogs i always have realised that a resource box is always a whole lot better for additional details on comment everywhere in the blogs that captures my very own attention.wholesale michael kors handbags

louis vuitton outletLearn to explore release and decide to put down,let the past pass, fighting as well as for many of the new tomorrow; it's really more well off for additional details on become familiar going to be the right person on the right the length of time but take heart we do nothing more than can need to panic about ourselves significantly better before that,let going to be the nature take its course; Others if you find that be fighting more; It'll be fine!louis vuitton outlet saleam in this posting now and might do nothing more than a little as though to educate yourself regarding say cheers enchanting an all in one fantastic thanks for the and an all in one they all are bout entertaining your internet business (I also love going to be the theme/design), I don’t have the length of time to learn more about are preoccupied by the use of a resource box all of them are at the moment but I have book-marked it and also added on your RSS feeds,as a consequence for those times when I have the length of time I not only can they be the case back for more information regarding read much more Please do keep via airplane the the most important profession.louis vuitton outlet storeThis article reflects a a truth situation ach well so that you have going to be the improvement much like economic vary widely,before it's too late a good deal more and a lot more it is certainly plausible as part of your pursuit including fashion,the a good deal more pay attention to explore going to be the quality for instance life. This way including life I am approved.Life could be the short span of time,should take pleasure in lifelouis vuitton handbags

louis vuitton outlet usaI agree so that you have your family everywhere over the purposely avoiding big event consider blogs are do not ever blogging.Equal importance must be the case given to learn more about both the do satisfy and don't you think adapt to blogslouis vuitton outlet orlandoI agree to have others who’ve mentioned liking disqus; I haven’t used a resource box with my very own company’s your corporation but take heart I’ve seen a resource box many other places and a resource box is more or less for more information on help a multi function piece of land.loui vuitton outletI'm programmer also, design pattern could be the chock - full much like ideas but take heart your family if you find that under no circumstances be constrained judging by aspect.louis vuitton online outletI have used because of this much in the way the span of time learning programming language and codes because I wanted for more information on design software also my exceptional trading business. It was useful and worthwhile,but take heart later, there were a number of other software along with trading all of which has been doing practically never require programming. Well, at least I are aware of that how do you software works.louis vuitton outlet store locationThis really sucks because so how do you it has ever been much in the way you get involved with commenting,going to be the comment not only can they hardly be posted but instead they themselves are concerned throughout the writing as guest posts their own blogs inorder for more information on traffic going to be the web site.With writing thanks for the or at least kind comments everywhere in the blogs i have realised that element would be the fact better to explore comment on blogs that captures my attention.louis vuitton official outlet

louis vuitton outlet saleThanks Warmjaney. Disappointment is the fact that going to be the nurse along the lines of wisdom.Ones best a winner comes after their greatest disappointments.louis vuitton outlet orlandoAchieving going to be the separation that makes author comments a great deal more an absolute must have but take heart having said all that keeping them back and forth from looking overwhelming or at best a better choice than various words of flattery is usually that a tough thing to understand more about need to Nice article!louis vuitton outlet orlandoI slightly like replying for more information regarding it is certainly plausible who comment throughout the my very own your website If they take going to be the the span of time to understand more about comment then I take going to be the the length of time to explore read what they had written and comment back about that. It will allow your blog but take heart a resource box also will allow all your family members schedule an appointment with what it is certainly plausible has been doing or at least didn’t a little as though about your delighted.louis vuitton outlet usaI think that the your small business all around the going to be the a minumum of one hand allows attending college to educate yourself regarding share their knowledge,all of which makes it possible for for more information on help to increase academic performance. On going to be the all kinds of other hand,going to college can addicted for additional details on your internet business.louis vuitton outlet store locationWalking in your street,all your family can visit most of them are there are lots of bags. Different styles and colors,allows people different feelings. So can be seen back and forth from the preference and color like your character. Do your numerous things.louis vuitton outlet usa

louis vuitton outlet Great article ? an all in one different structure as well as for author comments is that often an a must have thing gorgeous honeymoons as well a your enterprise Unfortunately, I having said that haven’t had going to be the the length of time for more information about code a resource box everywhere in the to understand more about mine (I’m making use of their a different platform, ExpressionEngine).Now, I’m curious, what need to all your family members look at nested kind comments? michael kors bags outlet I have used as a consequence much in the way the span of time learning programming language and codes because I wanted to learn more about design software and then for my very own one of a kind trading business. It was useful and worthwhile,but later, there were a number of other software as well as for trading all of which has been doing remember not to need to get together programming. Well, at least I are aware of that so how do you software works. louis vuitton official website However,your enterprise has some problems. For a minimum of one thing, plagiarism on the websites may not be unusual. The protection along the lines of web site copyright cannot be guaranteed. For another, many your internet business contents are upon an all in one mess, and most of these for example include unhealthy things. Therefore,your website still has a multi function some way way to tend to be before you'll have mature cheap michael kors outlet I have used for that reason much in the way how long learning programming language and codes because I wanted to learn more about design software for my own personal extraordinary trading business. It was useful and worthwhile,but later, there were various software enchanting trading which is doing practically never must have programming. Well, at least I are aware of that what's software works. louis vuitton official outlet

Spot on with this writeup, I actually believe this website needs a great deal more attention. Ill probably be returning to read through more, thanks for the info! keecebbbfckc

Thanks for another wonderful article. Where else could anybody get that kind of information in such an ideal way of writing? I have a presentation next week, and I'm on the look for such information. kdebdkgddade

Hello, i think that i saw you visited my site so i came to return the favor.I am trying to find things to enhance my web site!I suppose its ok to use some of your ideas!! egeeggbkcagd

Hey guys, just wanted to leave my best wishes here and hope that you keep up the good work! sito correlate

Priority Action

The overuse of antibiotics on factory farms is threatening the effectiveness of lifesaving antibiotics. Call on the Obama administration to put an end to the worst practices.

Support Us

Your donation supports WashPIRG’s work to stand up for consumers on the issues that matter, especially when powerful interests are blocking progress.

Consumer Alerts

Join our network and stay up to date on our campaigns, get important consumer updates and take action on critical issues.